SteriPEN vs LifeStraw – Their Strengths and Weaknesses Examined

LifeStraw vs SteriPEN

LifeStraw vs SteriPEN

Water filters are essential for backpackers, campers and survival kits. Two of the most common are the LifeStraw and SteriPEN. At first glance, they may seem like they’re very similar, but they’re actually very different.

The LifeStraw is an easy to use straw style water filter that removes bacteria and protozoa. The SteriPEN is a UV water purifier which kills bacteria, protozoa, and viruses 1 liter of water at a time, but doesn’t filter water.

Let’s look at the strengths and weaknesses of the LifeStraw and SteriPEN so you can figure out which one is going to be best for you.

LifeStraw or SteriPEN – Which Should You Choose

When you first look at the LifeStraw and SteriPEN you may think that they’re similar to one another, but they’re actually completely different! The LifeStraw is a water filter and the SteriPEN is a water purifier.

LifeStraw vs. SteriPENLifeStrawSteriPEN
Dimensions (W x H x D)9″ x 1.2″ Dia7.3″ x 1.6″ x 1.3″
Weight1.62 oz.5 oz.
Does it remove Protozoa/BacteriaYesYes
Does it remove VirusesNoYes
Filter TypeHollow Filter MembraneUV-C Sterilization
Battery TypeN/AInternal
Battery LifeN/A50 Liters of Water
InterfaceN/AUSB
Filter/Lamp Life1000 Gallons1000 Gallons


LifeStraw

The LifeStraw is the original straw-style water filter designed for hikers, bikers, and other people that enjoy the outdoors. It removes 99.999% of bacteria, parasites, and microplastics.

  • Length: 9″
  • Diameter: 1.2″
  • Weight: 1.62 oz.
  • Filter Life: 1,000 Gallons
[P_REVIEW post_id=21830 visual=’full’]

Do LifeStraws really work?

LifeStraws work extremely well. They remove more than 99% of all bacteria and parasites. This means it takes out 99.999999% of waterborne bacteria (this includes e.coli and salmonella) and 99.999% of waterborne parasites (including giardia and cryptosporidium).

It also removes all but the smallest microplastics and sediment.

Can you drink any water with the LifeStraw?

LifeStraws are a filter so they remove the sediment, bacteria, and protozoa from the water before you drink it. This means that you can grab a gross, dirty glass of water and just drink it through the LifeStraw without a problem. LifeStraws don’t filter fuel and other chemicals out of the water so you need to be sure that there isn’t any chemical contamination in the water that you plan to drink.

They also don’t remove viruses. If you suspect that the water has viruses of some kind in it, then you need to go with some other method of getting it clean enough to drink. If this is the case you can boil the water before drinking it through the LifeStraw. This will kill the viruses (as well as the protozoa and bacteria).

It also will not filter out salt from water. So while it may remove the bacteria and any parasites from saltwater, you still can’t safely drink it unless you remove the salt some other way.

How many times can you use a LifeStraw?

The long life of the LifeStraw is one of its best selling points! You can filter about 1,000 gallons of water with one LifeStraw. That’s about 5 years worth of water.

You can read our entire LifeStraw review here.

Do LifeStraws remove viruses?

LifeStraws can’t remove viruses. Viruses are too small to be filtered out by most filters including the LifeStraw.

How do you clean a LifeStraw filter?

LifeStraws can’t be broken down and cleaned like some other water filters. The best that you can do is to blow out the LifeStraw after each use and leave both ends open so the filter can dry out.

You can also suck some clean water up into the filter and then blow it back out. Of course, you need to have clean water sitting around for this to work.

When you’re using a LifeStraw, you need yo keep in mind that the end that goes into the water can possibly be contaminated. Keep it out of any clean water you have unless you don’t care that you can contaminate it.

What kind of filter does LifeStraw use?

LifeStraws use a hollow filter microfiltration membrane style filter. Water is forced through the .2 micron pores of the filter as you suck up water.


SteriPEN

The SteriPEN is a lightweight UV water purifier designed to quickly make water clean and safe for drinking. It eliminated bacteria and protozoa like most water filters, but it also kills viruses which filters can’t.

  • Weight: 5 oz.
  • Length: 7.3″
  • Width: 1.6″
  • Bulb Life: 1,000 Gallons
[P_REVIEW post_id=39057 visual=’full’]

Does the SteriPEN really work?

The SteriPEN kills 99.9% of all bacteria, protozoa, and viruses. It either flat out kills or deactivates them which means that they can’t reproduce or make you sick.

This big difference is that the SteriPEN doesn’t filter anything out. You’ll deactivate or kill anything in the water, but you’re still going to drink it along with any sediment that’s in the water.

One of the best things that UV sterilization does (or doesn’t do) is not add any chemicals to your water. If this important to you, then you’re really going to like the SteriPEN!

How does UV light kill bacteria?

UV light is a type of radiation. UV-C, the type used to disinfect water, is normally blocked by the ozone but bulbs like the one in the SteriPEN produce UV-C because it’s so effective in stopping microorganisms.

When these microorganisms are hit by the UV light, it damages their DNA and stops them from being able to reproduce. This means that you can’t get sick from them because they need to be able to reproduce to make you sick. By reproducing in your body they eventually cause negative health effects.

Can you drink any water with the SteriPEN?

The SteriPEN kills or damages microorganisms. That’s it. This means that you can’t drink chemically contaminated water or water that has salt in it.

How long does a SteriPEN last?

The SteriPEN can disinfect 50 liters of water per charge and the bulb life lasts for about 8000 activations. 1 activation disinfects .5 liter and 2 activations disinfect 1 liter of water.

What kind of batteries does a SteriPEN use?

This SeriPEN has a rechargeable battery that comes as part of the unit. The USB charging port allows you to recharge the SteriPEN with any of your USB power packs or solar panels. This makes it great for me since I usually have a solar panel and battery pack with me.

You can find other versions of the SteriPEN that use AA batteries if you like batteries that can be replaced better. There are benefits of both so go with what works for you!

Can you use a SteriPEN in a metal bottle?

SteriPENs can be used in pretty much any container that you have. Glass, metal, plastic, etc. The container actually blocks any possible harmful UV light that gets produced.

LifeStraw vs SteriPEN – Which is Best for You

Choosing between the LifeStraw and SteriPEN can be confusing but it’s actually pretty straight forward in my opinion.

Do you need to treat your water for viruses?

Most of the worst waterborne diseases that you’re going to find in North America are caused by either bacteria or protozoa. This means that you’re probably not going to need to kill off viruses in your drinking water. The one exception is the possibility of Hepatitis A.

Hepatitis A is spread when human feces from an infected person make it into a water supply. Hepatitis A is found all across the U.S. but it’s rare for it to be found in water supplies.

If you think you’re likely to contact water that’s contaminated by human waste, then the SteriPEN is what you want.

Most people will be better off with the LifeStraw

Anyone looking for an inexpensive filter that is easy to use and works well in cloudy water should go for the LifeStraw.

Conclusion

The LifeStraw and SteriPEN are two common pieces of equipment used to make potentially contaminated water sources clean and drinkable.

Both are small and pretty easy to use, but the similarities really end there. The LifeStraw is a personal water filter and the SteriPEN is a UV water sterilizer that can make drinking water for an individual or a group.

In the end, I’d suggest going for the cheaper LifeStraw over the SteriPEN unless you need to treat water for multiple people or you think you’re going to need to treat water for viruses.

Scroll to Top